Pros and cons of forex hedging
Advantages of hedging in forex
Interested in giving hedging a try? Take a look at some of the benefits it can offer you:
Diversification: Lots of financial assets can be hedged, such as stocks, commodities, and currencies. By applying this concept and its specific techniques to each case, you can make sure to protect yourself from risks in multiple scenarios.
Risk management: Investments will always come with an inherent risk, but that doesn’t mean you can’t take an active approach to minimize those risks if the situation calls for it.
Controlled losses: Losing is a continuous possibility with investing. By using hedging, however, you can try to control those losses, getting them to a number you’re comfortable with.
Certainty in prices: While the value of assets will always vary, it’s possible to maintain fixed prices in certain situations with strategies like futures contracts, and call and put options.
In summary, consider hedging if you’re particularly worried about your risks in a specific transaction, and if you think it’s possible to significantly reduce them by using a planned strategy.
Drawbacks and risks of hedging
As with any approach, hedging also has its disadvantages. It’s important to consider these downsides before trying it:
Costs: Hedging isn’t free. Every specific strategy will have its cost - whether that be its direct cost, such as premium payments, or the indirect cost of being on the wrong side of a hedge during a market change.
Restricted gains: By losing your risk, you will inevitably reduce your chance of gains at the same time. It’s always a matter of deciding what you’re willing to lose in a specific situation. After all, sometimes it’s more important to guarantee fewer losses than to obtain more gains.
Complexity: Even for experienced investors, hedging can get tricky. It will require complex market analysis, predictions of changes in economics, and even political research. All of this can get too troublesome, especially for beginners.
Wrong opinions: Mistakes happen and your thought biases can sometimes get in the way of critical thinking. What makes it even harder is that emotional investing can happen more frequently during times of crisis, causing you to overhedge or even choose the wrong hedge option.
Keep in mind those factors before setting up your hedging strategy, particularly when it comes to costs and their total price.
Common mistakes in forex hedging
Hedging is meant to protect traders from losses, but there are situations when it can backfire and lead to losses.
If you overhedge, your profit will just cancel out. Plus you end up paying extra in spreads, commissions, and swap fees while making little to no profit.
If you ignore the costs, the hedge becomes more expensive than the risk.
A hedge should be a temporary protection, but if you hold it too long, it will result in lost profit and extra fees.
How to implement a forex hedging strategy
The idea of hedging might seem straightforward, but it still requires careful planning and execution. Here’s our step-by-step guide to implementing a hedging strategy.
Step 1: Assess your risk exposure
Evaluating the risks associated with your trades is the first necessary step. Consider the following factors.
Market conditions — is there upcoming economic news, such as an interest rate decision, that might increase volatility?
Trade direction — are you concerned about a potential price drop if you are long, or a price increase if you are short?
Leverage and account size — do you have enough margin to support hedge positions?
Currency correlations — do you trade multiple pairs, and how do they interact?
Step 2: Choose the right hedging strategy
Once you understand your risk, choose the most suitable approach: direct hedging, correlation hedging, options hedging or forward contracts. They work well for different purposes — choose an approach for you.
Step 3: Monitor and adjust your hedge
Remember — hedging is not a “set it and forget it” strategy. Don’t forget to track your positions and make changes if needed. Check market conditions, adjust positions size and exit at the right time.
Practical example of hedging
Let’s suppose you’re a trader with a long position in EURUSD. Right now the exchange rate is 1.1000, meaning you can buy €10 000 with $11 000.
Because you heard some news about the economy in Europe, you’re optimistic that the euro will get even stronger, growing to an exchange rate of 1.1500, meaning that those €10 000 would now be worth $11 500 - a profit of $500 (not considering fees for this example).
This is all good news, but what if something unexpected happens and the euro actually gets way weaker? That’s where hedging could come in handy.
By using a strategy like a put option, for example, you could protect yourself from sudden variations and make sure you would be able to sell your euros at a predetermined favorable price, even if something undesirable happens.
The table below shows both scenarios playing out with numbers:
The exchange rate is 1.1000 and you buy €10 000 with $11 000
For protection, you also buy a put option for $50 that fixes the exchange rate at 1.0900
Scenario 1: Euro gets stronger | Exchange rate: 1.1300 | With the put option: You don’t use it because the euro is now worth more. Your profit is $250 ($300 minus the $50 payment). | Without the put option: You get $11 300 and your profit is $300. |
Scenario 2: Euro gets weaker | Exchange rate: 1.0700 | With the put option: You use it and get $10 900. Your total loss is $150 ($100 plus the $50 payment). | Without the put option: You get $10 700 and your total loss is $300. |
As you can see, when things went wrong, the put option you bought was responsible for making you lose only half the amount you would have lost originally. Instead of $300, you only lost $150.
However, when things were better and the euro increased in value, the put option reduced the margin of your gains. Instead of getting $300, your profit was only $250.
This is why it’s really important to consider hedging carefully, with a case-by-case analysis, and making sure you understand the possibilities for each one.
Forex hedging vs. other risk management strategies
Stop-loss orders vs. hedging
Stop-loss order | Hedging |
Automatically closes a trade at a predetermined loss level. Ensures protection but locks in a loss once triggered. There’s no opportunity for recovery in case the market reverses.
| Offsets losses with gains from a hedge trade, keeping the position open. Can be adjusted dynamically — you don’t have to exit the trade completely. Often involves additional costs (spreads, premiums for options, etc).
|
Both strategies are good, but sometimes a simple stop-loss order is the smarter and cheaper option than hedging.
Want to limit losses without extra costs? Go for a stop-loss order — unlike hedging, it doesn’t involve fees or a premium.
A stop-loss is also a better option for short-term traders, because hedging is too slow and costly for them. A stop-loss automatically protects your position, so you don’t have to worry about market fluctuations.
Hedging demands active management, so it may be a handful for a new trader. If you want a simple strategy, stop-losses are a stress-free approach.
Diversification vs. hedging
Hedging protects individual trades, but diversification protects your entire portfolio, spreading the risks across different currency pairs or even different asset classes. It does that without the extra costs. Also, hedging constantly can limit your profit potential, while diversification allows you to benefit from market fluctuations.
FAQ: Key questions about forex hedging
Does forex hedging guarantee profits?
No, not exactly. Hedging is about protection, not guaranteed profits — it’s an insurance policy. Yes, it does help to minimize losses, but it by no means promises gains.
Can beginners use forex hedging effectively?
Hedging can be complex, so be cautious and practice with a demo account first. Start with small hedging positions.
Which hedging strategy is best for short-term traders?
Direct hedging and correlation hedging are the most effective strategies, if you are a short-term trader. If you need a quick hedge for a volatile event, direct hedging is the simplest. But if you want more flexibility, correlation hedging is a strong alternative.
Summary
Hedging is an advanced method to mitigate risk and hinder potential bigger losses. While it can be extra useful for those trading in highly volatile markets like forex, it’s a strategy that comes with its own costs and risks.
As an investor it’s up to you to decide how you will manage your exposure to loss, whether through elaborate hedging strategies, or just relying on long-term safer investments.
As always, count on FBS to trade safely and to learn more about investments and finance.
